I second the below - though I would also look at the Sony PD170

(a bit better reputation for sturdiness, and easier to get top-class

lens converters for it), and add that the XL1s (and TRV950 and

variants) would be among my last choice among current small

3-CCD camcorders for overall image quality. Have you looked at

the JVC and Panasonic shoulder-mounts at slightly higher prices?

BTW, there is also the *possibility* that a VERY interesting

3-CCD Sony HDTV camcorder (under $5000) *may* appear

soon. This would likely provide better quality images than the

other options, with native 16:9 included...

--

David Ruether

d_ruether@hotmail.com

http://www.David-Ruether-Photography.com

"John B., Indianapolis" <johntakethisout@indytakethisout.net>

wrote in message news:408776e3$0$46511$39cecf19@news.twtelecom.net...

> Get the Panasonic DVX100A -- it's better audio-wise (I assume that's why

> your're asking here) and everyone I've talked to who owns one loves it.

> I know several people who have sold their XL-1's to buy the Panasonic.

>

> Of course, with NAB upon us, this could change. And, naturally, your

> choice depends upon your individual needs, but since you simply asked

> for a recommendation, get the DVX100A.

>

> Beyond that, my recommendation for good sound is to hire a good sound

> person -- as someone else said here, "It ain't the piano, it's the piano

> player." Don't be afraid to talk to a pro. There are many sound people

> who will sometimes help out an independent filmmaker with a special rate

> if the timing fits in between regular paying gigs.

>

> Learning to hire professionals is a major step on your road to becoming

> a professional.

>

> Good luck.

>

> John B., Indianapolis

> Blue_Iron wrote:

> > I need opinions or recommendations on what DV video camera I should

> > purchase for film making and also any recommendations for sound and

> > editing equipment?

> >

> > Canon's XL-1S seems great and Sony's PD 150 has had many good

> > reviews, but I'd like to get info from people with current filming

> > experience with them.

> >

> > Suggestions please :D I am finishing up a script with shooting

> > starting next September.

> >

> > Thank you.

> >

> > Blue_Iron